Creativity, Inc.
Ed Catmull with Amy Wallace
Creativity, Inc. is Ed Catmull's account of how Pixar built a culture that could keep making original films without losing its nerve. Its practical core is three habits: protect new ideas while they are still bad, show work in progress to a small, candid group early, and give feedback that names the problem without dictating the fix.
Every Pixar film you love was, for a long stretch, a bad film. Catmull's book is about what a team does during that stretch.
The book in essence
Catmull co-founded Pixar and led it from early computer graphics research through Toy Story and on to the merger with Disney, where he also took over Disney Animation. The book, written with journalist Amy Wallace, does two things. It is a memoir of the Lucasfilm years, Steve Jobs and the long road to the first feature. It is also a management argument: creativity depends less on genius than on building conditions in which flawed early work can survive and improve.
Two of its images stick. The "ugly baby" is the new idea: awkward, incomplete and easy to kill. The "Beast" is the organization's appetite for output, schedules and budgets. The Beast is necessary, but it will eat the baby if nobody protects it. Most of the book's tools are ways of balancing the two: the Braintrust, notes, postmortems and tolerance for early mistakes.
Some honest caveats. The book is written by the boss, so it describes the system as designed more than as everyone experienced it. In 2017 John Lasseter, Pixar's creative chief and a central figure in the book, took leave amid allegations of inappropriate conduct and later left the company. The episode is a reminder that candor rituals in a meeting room don't guarantee safety across a whole company. Some of the Disney chapters also read like corporate history. Even so, the ideas travel well, even to a three-person team.
Who it's for
- People who lead creative teams in design, product, film, games or agencies
- Makers who share work in progress and dread feedback
- Managers trying to make honest critique normal without making it brutal
- Readers curious about Pixar's history and Steve Jobs's second act
Who it's not for
- — Readers looking for individual creativity exercises or a book of daily techniques
- — Anyone who wants a critical history of Pixar written from the outside
Key lessons
01
Protect the ugly baby
Catmull admits that every Pixar film starts out bad, and it is the most freeing line in the book. A new idea doesn't arrive whole. It arrives as a rough draft with one interesting thing in it. The early job is to keep it alive long enough to find out what that thing is, and to treat each failed version as information about what doesn't work. The threat is rarely a single critic. It is the "Beast": deadlines, budgets and pressure to show something polished. Protecting an idea means giving it a safe audience and time. It doesn't mean pretending it's already good.
A product designer in Manchester builds a prototype app for booking allotment plots. Her first testers are lost within minutes. Instead of scrapping it, she writes down exactly where each one stalled. All of them got stuck on the same thing: they couldn't tell which plots were free. Version two is built around a single map. The failure didn't judge the idea. It pointed to its center.
02
Build a small braintrust before you need one
Pixar's Braintrust is a group of experienced filmmakers who watch a movie in progress and talk about it frankly. Two rules make it work. The members are peers who understand the craft, and the group has no authority: the director decides what to do with what was said. That takes the politics out, because nobody is pleading with a boss. You don't need a studio to copy this. You need three or four people whose judgment you trust, an agreement made in advance to be candid with each other, and a habit of showing work before it's finished. Setting it up early matters, because asking for honesty in the middle of a crisis is much harder.
Two freelance illustrators and a copywriter in Leeds agree to meet on the first Monday of every month. Each brings one unfinished piece. The rule is twenty minutes of plain talk per piece, and the owner decides what to keep. Six months later, one of them lands a big client and starts to panic. The channel for frank feedback already exists.
03
Give notes that point, not prescribe
A good note tells the maker what happened to you as the audience, such as "I lost track of what she wants here" or "the middle drags." It doesn't hand over a solution. The maker knows the work better and usually finds a better fix than the critic would have. Pixar also practices "plussing": building on an idea instead of only knocking it down. Receiving notes is the other half of the skill. The instinct is to explain what you meant. The useful move is to listen, ask where exactly it went wrong, and decide later, after you've left the room.
A podcast producer plays a draft episode for a colleague. The colleague doesn't say "cut the intro and open with the interview." Instead, she says, "I started checking my phone around minute four." The producer resists the urge to explain and asks what was happening at that point. The fix she lands on is moving a story earlier, which is not what the colleague would have suggested.
Try this today
Pick one unfinished thing you've been hiding. Show it to one person you trust today and ask a single question: "Where did it lose you?" Write the answer down without replying.
Quick check
In Pixar's Braintrust, who decides what changes after a session?
By the book's standard, which is the most useful note?
Selected quotes
“Early on, all of our movies suck.”
“Be wrong as fast as you can.”
“Mistakes aren't a necessary evil. They aren't evil at all.”
“Getting the team right is the necessary precursor to getting the ideas right.”
