BookYol

Author

Ed Catmull

The computer scientist who co-founded Pixar and argued that a manager's real job is protecting creative people from fear.

1 book on BookYol

The story and the impact

Edwin Catmull studied physics and computer science at the University of Utah, earning his doctorate in 1974 during the formative years of computer graphics. There he made A Computer Animated Hand (1972), one of the earliest works of 3D computer animation, and his research contributed foundational techniques such as texture mapping. From the start, his ambition was a feature film made entirely by computer.

After leading the computer graphics lab at the New York Institute of Technology, he joined Lucasfilm in 1979 to run its computer division. In 1986 Steve Jobs bought that division and it became Pixar, with Catmull as a co-founder alongside Alvy Ray Smith. Pixar went on to release Toy Story (1995), the first fully computer-animated feature film. His technical work, including the development of Pixar's rendering technology, earned him several Academy Scientific and Technical Awards.

When Disney acquired Pixar in 2006, Catmull became president of both Pixar and Walt Disney Animation Studios and helped revive the latter. In 2014 he published Creativity, Inc., written with Amy Wallace, an account of how Pixar built a creative culture and how hard it was to sustain. He shared the 2019 ACM Turing Award with Pat Hanrahan for their contributions to 3D computer graphics.

The signature

Catmull starts from the assumption that every early idea is bad, and that this is normal. He called early versions of Pixar films ugly babies: fragile, unformed things that need protection rather than judgment. His method is to build structures that let a team look honestly at flawed work without anyone feeling attacked: the Braintrust, a group of experienced filmmakers who give a director candid notes but have no power to impose them; daily reviews of unfinished work; and postmortems after each film.

What makes his approach distinctive is that he treats culture as a problem that never stays solved. He writes less as a visionary than as a manager who kept discovering hidden problems inside his own successful company, and he insists that candor, failure and change must be actively managed rather than assumed. His recurring question is not how to find good ideas, but how to keep people safe enough to keep improving bad ones.

The questions they work on

  • What hidden forces make a successful creative culture decline?
  • How can a team give honest notes on unfinished work without fear?
  • Why should a manager expect early ideas to be bad?

Thinking tools

Limits and fair objections

Candour, protected by structure, is what keeps a creative company improving.

Catmull writes as the leader of the culture he describes, and a leader is not always the first to hear what people are afraid to say. As BookYol reads it, the book is frank about Pixar's mistakes, but an account from the top cannot fully show how safe candour felt further down; accounts from people throughout the studio are the missing half.

Stands on: examples · BookYol's reading

Failure is a necessary part of making something new, and managers should make it safe.

Pixar could absorb the cost of reworking films for years because it had exceptional talent, strong backing and early hits. As BookYol reads it, the principle holds, but most teams have to decide how much failure their budget and deadlines can carry, and the book says less about where to draw that line.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading

Mechanisms built at Pixar, such as the Braintrust, can be carried into other organisations.

The Braintrust depended on experienced people who respected each other's judgement and on a director who kept the final say. As BookYol reads it, the book offers principles rather than a template, and the mechanism copies well only where that respect already exists; installed without it, the meeting tends to become either polite or punishing.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading