BookYol

The Hard Thing About Hard Things

Ben Horowitz

The Hard Thing About Hard Things is Ben Horowitz's account of running a company through the periods most management books skip: when nothing works, the biggest customer is leaving and the CEO cannot show any of it. Its lessons: the Struggle is the job, not a verdict; nobody is coming to rescue you; a company must be able to hear bad news; and the hard decisions only the founder can make are what the founder is for.

The management books tell you how to set goals, run meetings and build culture, and none of them tell you what to do when you have three weeks of cash, a product that does not work and a team that thinks you are lying to them. Horowitz ran Loudcloud through exactly that during the dot-com collapse, and he wrote down what he wished someone had told him.

The book in essence

Horowitz's central observation is that hard things are hard because there is no formula: demoting a friend, laying off people who did nothing wrong, telling a customer the product is being discontinued. His book is not a method but a set of observations that make those decisions survivable. The Struggle, his name for the period when everything falls apart, comes to every great founder and is not a verdict on them. Nobody cares: Horowitz borrows the line from Al Davis, the Oakland Raiders owner, who gave it to the coach Bill Parcells. It removes both the comfort of explanation and the fantasy of rescue, because all that matters is what you will do. There are no silver bullets, only lead bullets: the unglamorous list, worked through in order. A company must be able to hear bad news, so the CEO tells it like it is, with the numbers, to the whole team. And the priority is fixed: take care of the people, the products and the profits, in that order.

Horowitz co-founded Loudcloud in 1999, steered it through the crash by selling its hosting business and turning the remainder into Opsware, which Hewlett-Packard later bought, and then co-founded the venture firm Andreessen Horowitz. The book mixes the memoir of those years with short chapters of advice, most of them opening with a rap lyric, and it is widely read among founders for its account of what running a company in a crisis feels like.

Who it's for

  • Founders in the Struggle right now, who need to hear that it is normal and that it is the job
  • Anyone about to make a decision that hurts someone whichever way it goes, and delaying it
  • First-time CEOs who have discovered that the books on leadership were written for peacetime

Who it's not for

  • — Readers looking for a method for the early search for product-market fit; The Lean Startup and The Mom Test cover that stage, and Horowitz begins where it ends
  • — Anyone who wants a calm book; it is written from the inside of a crisis and reads like it

Key lessons

01

The Struggle is the job, not a verdict

Horowitz describes the period when you wonder why you started, when everybody thinks you are an idiot but nobody will fire you, when you cannot sleep and everything you built looks like a mistake. His point in naming it is that every great entrepreneur goes through it, and that the worst response is to conclude it means something about you. Do not carry it alone; put the problem in front of the team.

A founder in Trabzon whose logistics app lost its two largest customers in the same month spent three weeks working past midnight without telling anyone. Reading the chapter, she recognised the symptoms and stopped treating them as proof she was the wrong person. She put the problem in front of her four engineers, and within a week one of them had proposed the cheaper service that won one customer back.

02

Nobody cares, so play the hand

Horowitz takes the line from Al Davis, the Oakland Raiders owner, who told the coach Bill Parcells, short of his best players, that nobody cares and he should just coach his team. For a CEO it means that when things go wrong, nobody cares why (not the press, not the board, not the employees). All the reasons it is not your fault are irrelevant to the people who depend on you; the only thing that matters is what you are going to do. There are no silver bullets, only lead bullets, so write the list of unglamorous fixes and work through it in order.

A founder in Ankara whose main supplier failed spent three weeks explaining the lost quarter to investors. When one said kindly that nobody cared why, he wrote the lead-bullet list instead: four suppliers to call, two customers to warn, one price to renegotiate. Nine days later the list was done; the explaining had produced nothing.

03

Tell it like it is

The instinct is to protect morale by keeping the numbers vague, and it is exactly backwards. A company that cannot hear bad news cannot fix it, and the smart people you hired are wasted on problems they are not allowed to see. Trust is built by saying hard things, and a team that learns the truth late learns that it was lied to, which damages morale more than the news itself.

A founder in Izmir told her team for three months that the company's largest contract was being renewed, after the client had already said no. When the truth surfaced through a delayed salary, three people resigned over the lie, not the money. Her successor as chief executive opened every Monday with the cash number on the whiteboard, and nobody else left that year.

04

People, products, profits, in that order

Hard decisions have to be made on incomplete information and explained in person to the people they affect. Horowitz's order of priority gives them a test: take care of the people first (honesty, managers who manage, training, a company worth working at even while it struggles), then the products, then the profits. A decision made in the reverse order is much harder to defend.

A founder in Istanbul kept her co-founder running engineering for a year after the team had outgrown him, and lost two senior engineers to the chaos. When she finally made the change, she made it herself, in person, with a real role designed for what he was good at. He stayed; the engineers did not return.

Try this today

Write down the one decision you have been delaying, set a date this week to make it on the information you have, and tell the person it affects yourself, in person.

Quick check

What does Horowitz mean by 'nobody cares'?

Why does Horowitz insist on telling the team bad news with the numbers?

Selected quotes

“Hard things are hard because there are no easy answers or recipes.”
Ben Horowitz · From the introduction; the book's explanation of why the management literature had nothing to say about the decisions it describes.Read the context →
“Take care of the people, the products, and the profits, in that order.”
Ben Horowitz · Horowitz's rule of priority for a company in trouble, and the test of whether a hard decision can be defended.Read the context →
“The Struggle is where greatness comes from.”
Ben Horowitz · From the chapter on the Struggle, after his list of what it feels like and his reminder that every great entrepreneur has been through it.Read the context →
The BookYol LetterTwo letters a week

After the last page

The best part of The Hard Thing About Hard Things is what you do with it.

Every Tuesday, one idea from a book worth your shelf, explained in five minutes. Every Friday, a small experiment to see if it holds up in your own week.

Tuesday

The Big Idea

One idea that challenges an assumption, explained properly, with its source.

Friday

The Small Experiment

One small thing to try before Monday, so the idea becomes something you do.

Inside every letter

  1. 01The idea
  2. 02Why it works
  3. 03Where it comes from
  4. 04One thing to try

No spam, no selling your address. Just the letters.