BookYol

Author

Napoleon Hill

The early self-help author whose 1937 book is still sold, and whose story about it does not hold up.

1 book on BookYol

The story and the impact

Napoleon Hill (1883–1970) was an American author, born in Virginia, who worked as a journalist and salesman before writing about success. His first large work, The Law of Success, appeared in 1928.

Think and Grow Rich, published in 1937 during the Depression, condensed his ideas into thirteen steps, from desire and a definite purpose to persistence and the 'master mind'. Hill said that Andrew Carnegie had commissioned the work and that it rested on interviews with hundreds of famous men; no independent record confirms the commission, and later reporting has questioned much of his life story.

The signature

Hill writes as a preacher of purpose: decide exactly what you want, write it down, plan for it, surround yourself with people who help, and refuse to quit. Mixed in are claims that thoughts themselves attract money and chapters BookYol leaves out. The useful kernel is practical and testable; the frame around it is not.

The questions they work on

  • What does it take to turn a wish into a definite, written goal?
  • Why do most people stop at the first setback?
  • How much of success comes from the people around us?

Thinking tools

  • Definite Chief AimUses and explains it

    A definite chief aim is Napoleon Hill's name for one clear, written goal with a deadline and a statement of what you will give in return, kept in view every day so that effort stops scattering across many half-wanted wishes.

    Learn it: Think and Grow Rich, Station 2
  • Organized PlanningUses and explains it

    Organized planning is Napoleon Hill's rule that a goal needs a practical written plan, built with help from others where needed and replaced quickly when it fails, because a failed plan is a temporary defeat rather than a final verdict.

    Learn it: Think and Grow Rich, Station 7
  • Mastermind GroupUses and explains it

    A mastermind group is Napoleon Hill's name for a small group of people who meet regularly and work in harmony toward a definite purpose, pooling knowledge and effort; stripped of his claim about a shared 'third mind', it describes a peer group that gives advice, accountability and contacts.

    Learn it: Think and Grow Rich, Station 9
  • Persistence HabitUses and explains it

    The persistence habit is Napoleon Hill's claim that most people quit at the first setback and that persistence can be built from a definite purpose, a plan and supportive people; it helps when it means keeping at a goal while changing the method, and hurts when it means repeating a plan that is not working.

    Learn it: Think and Grow Rich, Station 10
  • The Six Basic FearsUses and explains it

    The six basic fears are Napoleon Hill's list of the fears he said hold people back (poverty, criticism, ill health, loss of love, old age and death); the list is not scientific, but naming a fear specifically, rather than feeling a vague dread, is a practical first step to acting despite it.

    Learn it: Think and Grow Rich, Station 11

Limits and fair objections

Think and Grow Rich rests on Hill's interviews with Andrew Carnegie and hundreds of successful men.

No independent record confirms that Carnegie commissioned Hill or that the interviews took place as described, and investigative reporting has documented a pattern of exaggeration and failed ventures in Hill's life. BookYol's reading: treat the book as one man's motivational synthesis, not as research.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Matt Novak, 'The Untold Story of Napoleon Hill, the Greatest Self-Help Scammer of All Time', Gizmodo, 2016

Repeating a goal or a positive statement to yourself every day makes it come true.

Research on positive self-statements found that they helped people with high self-esteem slightly but left people with low self-esteem feeling worse, because the statement clashed with what they believed. BookYol's reading: rereading a written goal can keep attention on it; it does not make the goal happen.

Stands on: research · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Wood, Perunovic & Lee, 'Positive Self-Statements: Power for Some, Peril for Others', Psychological Science, 2009