BookYol

Author

Daniel Kahneman

The psychologist who won the Nobel Prize in economics for showing how people actually decide.

2 books on BookYol

The road of their thinking

Think with Daniel Kahneman's tools

12 Stations through two of Kahneman's books, from the biases that bend a single judgment to the noise that scatters many, ending in a decision hygiene routine of your own for a judgment you make often.

12 Stations · Station 1 is free

Open the road

The story and the impact

Daniel Kahneman, born in Tel Aviv in 1934 and raised partly in occupied France, spent his career at the Hebrew University, the University of British Columbia, Berkeley and Princeton. With Amos Tversky he mapped the systematic errors in human judgement, work that produced prospect theory and earned him the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 2002, awarded to a psychologist for changing economics.

Thinking, Fast and Slow, published in 2011, is his account of that life's work for a general reader: two systems of thought, the fast intuitive one and the slow deliberate one, and the biases that follow from letting the first do the second's job. Noise, written with Olivier Sibony and Cass R. Sunstein and published in 2021, turned from bias to the unwanted variability in judgements that should agree. He died in March 2024.

The signature

Kahneman's signature is doubt applied with rigor, above all to himself. He treats confidence as a feeling rather than evidence, distrusts stories that explain too neatly, and keeps returning to the gap between how a decision feels and how it will look later. The prose is patient and unflattering, and it is precisely why readers trust it.

The questions they work on

  • Why do intelligent people make errors of judgement that are systematic and predictable?
  • When does a confident intuition deserve trust, and when is confidence only a feeling?
  • Why do professionals who should agree reach different judgements on the same case?
  • What can an organisation change in how it decides, given that no one can simply decide to be less biased?

Thinking tools

Limits and fair objections

Subtle primes, such as words or images a person barely notices, reliably change later behaviour, as a chapter of Thinking, Fast and Slow presents them.

Many of the priming studies the book relied on failed when other laboratories repeated them with larger samples. Kahneman himself said publicly that he had placed too much faith in underpowered studies. As BookYol reads it, the book's core account of fast and slow thinking stands on far broader evidence than its priming chapter, which is best read with caution.

Stands on: research · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Schimmack, Heene & Kesavan, 'Reconstruction of a Train Wreck: How Priming Research Went off the Rails', Replicability-Index (2017), with Kahneman's published reply

The mind can usefully be described as two systems, a fast intuitive one and a slow deliberate one.

Kahneman presents the systems as useful fictions, not as separate parts of the brain, but critics argue that the split is too neat: intuitive and deliberate judgements may run on common rules, and fast heuristics are often accurate rather than error-prone. As BookYol reads it, the two systems are a strong teaching device and a weaker theory of how the mind works.

Stands on: research and argument · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Kruglanski & Gigerenzer, 'Intuitive and deliberate judgments are based on common principles', Psychological Review (2011)

Noise is as damaging as bias, and organisations should reduce it with decision hygiene.

The evidence that noise exists and is large is strong; the evidence that each hygiene practice reduces it in real organisations, at an acceptable cost, is thinner, and some variability is wanted, as in creative work or competing forecasts. Noise itself acknowledges costs such as rigidity and gaming. As BookYol reads it, the diagnosis is firmer than any single cure.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading