BookYol

Author

Benjamin Graham

The father of value investing: the Columbia professor who turned stock-picking into analysis and made the margin of safety a rule.

1 book on BookYol

The story and the impact

Benjamin Graham was born in London in 1894, and his family emigrated to New York when he was an infant. He grew up in financial hardship after his father's early death. He graduated from Columbia University in 1914 and, instead of the academic career open to him, went to work on Wall Street. There he built a reputation as an unusually rigorous analyst who read company balance sheets when most of the market traded on tips and rumour.

In the 1920s he began managing money for clients through an investment partnership that became the Graham-Newman Corporation, run with Jerome Newman. The 1929 crash and the Depression that followed hit his fund hard. Graham treated those losses as data and spent the rest of his career building methods that would protect capital first. From 1928 he taught investing at Columbia Business School, and in 1934 he published «Security Analysis» with his colleague David Dodd. The book set the framework for professional security analysis.

In 1949 he published «The Intelligent Investor», which brought the same principles to the general reader. He revised it repeatedly during his lifetime, and the last revised edition appeared in 1973. Warren Buffett studied under Graham at Columbia and later worked for him at Graham-Newman. Buffett has called it by far the best book about investing ever written. Graham died in 1976 in France. His ideas on value, discipline and risk remain the foundation of what is now called value investing.

The signature

Graham's method starts with a definition rather than a forecast. An investment, he wrote, is an operation that, upon thorough analysis, promises safety of principal and an adequate return, and anything else is speculation. He did not ask readers to predict the market. He asked them to know what a business is worth, buy only when the price sits well below that conservative estimate, and let that gap, the margin of safety, absorb their mistakes and bad luck.

What makes his approach his own is that it puts psychology at the centre. His parable of Mr. Market describes a moody business partner who offers you a new price every day, sometimes euphoric and sometimes despairing. The parable teaches that market quotations are there to be used, not obeyed. He also separated the defensive investor from the enterprising one. The returns you can expect depend on the effort and knowledge you are willing to commit, not on how much you want to earn. For Graham, temperament mattered more than brilliance.

The questions they work on

  • What is the difference between investing and speculating with your money?
  • How do you stay calm and rational when the market swings sharply?
  • How much effort should an ordinary investor put into choosing investments?

Thinking tools

Limits and fair objections

Careful analysis of a company's accounts can find stocks selling well below their value.

Graham's own later view qualified this. Near the end of his life he said that elaborate security analysis no longer paid off as it once had, because many analysts were now doing the same work and bargains were harder to find. As BookYol reads it, the deep bargains of his early chapters are much rarer in today's widely followed markets, while the discipline behind them, buying only with a margin of safety, still holds.

Stands on: an argument · The author's own caveat

Evaluated against: Benjamin Graham, interview with the Financial Analysts Journal (1976)

Buying with a margin of safety below intrinsic value protects the investor from error and bad luck.

The protection is only as good as the estimate of value it rests on. As BookYol reads it, a business can look cheap on its past record while its future is getting worse, and a cautious-looking estimate can still be wrong; the margin of safety reduces risk, but it does not remove the need to understand why a price is low.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading

A defensive investor can do well by buying a diversified list of large, sound companies by set rules.

Graham wrote before low-cost index funds existed. As BookYol reads it, his own reasoning, that most people lack the time or temperament to beat the market and should aim for steady, adequate returns, now points most defensive investors towards a broad index fund, the approach John Bogle later built his firm on, rather than towards selecting individual stocks by Graham's criteria.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: John C. Bogle, The Little Book of Common Sense Investing (2007)