BookYol

Author

Ichiro Kishimi

The Kyoto philosopher who turned Alfred Adler's psychology into a Socratic dialogue about freedom, courage and happiness.

2 books on BookYol

The road of their thinking

Think with Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga's tools

12 Stations through Kishimi and Koga's two Adlerian dialogues, from asking what a behaviour is for to respect, encouragement and love in practice, ending in a one-page practice for one real relationship.

12 Stations · Station 1 is free

Open the road

The story and the impact

Ichiro Kishimi was born in Kyoto in 1956. He trained as a philosopher at Kyoto University, specialising in Western classical philosophy and above all in Plato. That grounding in the Platonic dialogue, where truth is reached through patient question and answer, would later give his best-known work its shape.

Alongside philosophy, Kishimi took up the Individual Psychology of Alfred Adler, the Austrian psychiatrist long overshadowed by Freud and Jung. Adler became his life's work. He has counselled, lectured and written extensively on Adlerian thought in Japan, and he has translated Adler's writings into Japanese, presenting him as a thinker whose ideas belong to everyday life, not only to the clinic.

In 2013 he published The Courage to Be Disliked with the writer Fumitake Koga. The book stages five nights of conversation between a philosopher and a sceptical young man who arrives determined to refute him. It became a bestseller in Japan, reached readers across Asia and, after its English translation in 2018, a worldwide audience. The two authors continued the dialogue in The Courage to Be Happy (2016). Together the books introduced Adler's psychology to a generation of general readers.

The signature

Kishimi's method is the dialogue itself. He does not lecture. He lets the youth push back hard, voicing every objection a reader might have, and answers each one patiently until the argument holds. The ideas are Adler's, but the form is Socratic: understanding is earned through resistance, not handed over as advice.

At the heart of his reading of Adler is a refusal to treat the past as destiny. He argues that we are not driven by our traumas but use our experiences in the service of goals we have chosen, which means we can choose differently. From this follow his signature themes: all problems are interpersonal problems; the separation of tasks, so that we stop carrying what belongs to others; relationships built on equality rather than praise or rebuke; contributing to others as the ground of a sense of worth; and living earnestly in the here and now. Being disliked by some people, in his view, is the price of that freedom.

The questions they work on

  • Why does asking what a behaviour is for help more than asking where it came from?
  • How do we tell our own tasks from the ones that belong to someone else?
  • What do respect and encouragement look like at work and at home, without praise or rebuke?

Thinking tools

Limits and fair objections

The past does not determine us; what we call trauma is a meaning we choose to give our experiences.

The goal-oriented question is a useful tool for everyday habits, but research on adverse childhood experiences links early abuse and household dysfunction with lasting effects on adult health. As BookYol reads it, the books' sharpest lines on trauma fit ordinary patterns of avoidance; serious trauma calls for professional care, not only a change of perspective.

Stands on: research · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Felitti et al., 'Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study', American Journal of Preventive Medicine (1998)

Praise should be dropped altogether, in classrooms and in management, because it makes relationships vertical and people dependent.

A large meta-analysis found that expected tangible rewards tended to undermine interest in a task, but that informative positive feedback often supported it. As BookYol reads it, the books' case is strongest against rankings and rewards that turn work into a contest, and weaker against specific, honest feedback on the work itself.

Stands on: research and argument · BookYol's reading

Evaluated against: Deci, Koestner & Ryan, 'A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation', Psychological Bulletin (1999)

All problems are interpersonal problems.

The claim works as a lens: many worries that seem private turn out to be about how a particular person will see us. Taken literally, it overreaches, because illness, debt or a broken machine are problems in their own right. As BookYol reads it, the idea is most useful once the practical part of a problem is clear and the worry keeps going anyway.

Stands on: an argument · BookYol's reading